Agreed but again it's just expanding on my negative point. New users may get turned off if they see a down vote right away
I think it's important to distinguish between "I got a downvote! What a crappy user base!" and "that post has a lot of downvotes. It must not be very good."
Also under negatives:
2. The change in karma affects visibility.
3. If downvotes provoke moderator/admin intervention as is being discussed, it creates more work for them.
4. It can color people's perceptions of the content of the post even if they don't realize it.
2. I think you mean reputation not karma?
3. Agreed
4. Agreed but again it's just expanding on my negative point. New users may get turned off if they see a down vote right away
Whoops! Heh. Yes, that's what I meant.
I think it's important to distinguish between "I got a downvote! What a crappy user base!" and "that post has a lot of downvotes. It must not be very good."