I would take Rodgers over Brady right now too and I'm pats fan. Rodgers has way more maneuverability then Brady. Thats actually Brady's biggest flaw if you put pressure on him he has a hard time. Whereas Rodgers, like you said is versatile, he takes off then still manages to throw the ball down feild.

As for Romo, maybe they ranked him lower because after he hurt his back he didn't do so great. In my book that makes him an even more impressive QB though, he managed to go out there with a messed up back and still make plays. I think more highly of him after season.